Comparison of methods for nitrous oxide emission estimation in full-scale activated sludge

Abstract

Nitrous oxide (N2O) gas transfer was studied in a full-scale process to correlate liquid phase N2O concentrations with gas phase N2O emissions and compare methods of determining the volumetric mass transfer coefficient, KLa. Off-gas and liquid phase monitoring were conducted at the Viikinmäki wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) over a two-week period using a novel method for simultaneous measurement of dissolved and off-gas N2O and O2 from the same location. KLa was calculated with three methods: empirically, based on aeration superficial velocity, from experimentally determined O2 KLa, and using a static value of best fit. The findings of this study indicated trends in local emitted N2O consistently matched trends in local dissolved N2O, but the magnitude of N2O emissions could not be accurately estimated without correction. After applying a static correction factor, the O2 method, using experimentally determined O2 KLa, provided the best N2O emission estimation over the data collection period. N2O emissions estimated using the O2 method had a root mean square error (RMSE) of 70.5 compared against measured concentrations ranging from 3 to 1,913 ppm and a maximum 28% error. The KLa value, and therefore the method of KLa determination, had a significant impact on estimated emissions.

Keywords

• full-scale
• gas transfer
• greenhouse gases
• nitrous oxide
• off-gas
• wastewater treatment