Safety assessment in dams due to downstream slope anomalies

Abstract

Recent cases of tailings dam failure in Brazil have demonstrated in the current methods of safety assessment of these structures. One of the most employed methods is the evaluation through routine inspections and audits, but this method is considered non-deterministic and affected by the expertise of the evaluator. This paper presents the results of numerical simulations of anomalies commonly found in safety inspections to measure the impact of these anomalies on the dam safety factor. The study was limited to numerical simulations of five types of dams (three downstream and two upstream dams), with varying embankment and tailings strength parameters, simulating different magnitudes of downstream slope anomalies (cracks, scour, and resurgence), totaling a sample space of 270 analyses. The results show that there were average reductions in safety ranging from 4% to 10% for scour simulations, 8% to 25% for resurgence, and 9% to 24% for cracking. The sample standard deviation of the analyses ranged from 8 to 12%. It was also observed that the combined effect of the anomalies showed proportional overlapping effects in reducing the range of safety. It was concluded that the simulated failures are important variables to be evaluated in inspections, not only for demonstrate deviations in the operation and maintenance of structures, but also to predict the magnitude of these failures in dam designs.

Keywords

• anomalies
• cracks
• scour
• resurgence
• factor of safety (fs)