Phenomenology and Mind (Aug 2017)

On Experiencing Meaning: Irreducible Cognitive Phenomenology and Sinewave Speech

  • John Joseph Dorsch

DOI
https://doi.org/10.13128/Phe_Mi-21120
Journal volume & issue
no. 12

Abstract

Read online

Upon first hearing sinewaves, all that can be discerned are beeps and whistles. But after hearing the original speech, the beeps and whistles sound like speech. The difference between these two episodes undoubtedly involves an alteration in phenomenal character. O’Callaghan (2011) argues that this alteration is non-sensory, but he leaves open the possibility of attributing it to some other source, e.g. cognition. I discuss whether the alteration in phenomenal character involved in sinewave speech provides evidence for cognitive phenomenology. I defend both the existence of cognitive phenomenology and the phenomenal contrast method, as each concerns the case presented here.

Keywords