Underlying genetic architecture of resistance to mastitis in dairy cattle: A systematic review and gene prioritization analysis of genome-wide association studies

Abstract

ABSTRACT: Mastitis, the most frequent disease in dairy cattle. Resistance to mastitis is a complex, polygenic trait controlled by several genes, each with small effects. Genome-wide association studies have been widely used to identify genomic variants associated with complex traits, including resistance to mastitis, to elucidate the underlying genetic architecture of the trait. However, no systematic review and gene prioritization analysis have been conducted to date on GWAS results for resistance to mastitis in dairy cattle. Hence, the objective was to perform a systematic review and gene prioritization analysis of GWAS studies to identify potential functional candidate genes associated with resistance to mastitis-related traits in dairy cattle. Four electronic databases were searched from inception to December 2020, supplemented with multiple sources of gray literature, to identify eligible articles. Annotation for genes and quantitative trait loci (QTL), and QTL enrichment analysis were conducted using GALLO. Gene prioritization analysis was performed by a guilty-by-association approach using GUILDify and ToppGene. From 52 articles included within this systematic review, 30 articles were used for further functional analyses. Gene and QTL annotation resulted in 9,125 and 43,646 unique genes and QTL, respectively, from 39 studies. In general, overlapping of genes across studies was very low (mean ± SD = 0.02% ± 0.07%). Most annotated genes were associated with somatic cell count-related traits and the Holstein breed. Within all annotated genes, 74 genes were shared among Holstein, Jersey, and Ayrshire breeds. Approximately 7.5% of annotated QTL were related to QTL class “health.” Within the health QTL class, 2.6 and 2.2% of QTL were associated with clinical mastitis and somatic cell count-related traits. Enrichment analysis of QTL demonstrated that many enriched QTL were associated with somatic cell score located in Bos taurus autosomes 5, 6, 16, and 20. The prioritization analysis resulted in 427 significant genes after multiple test correction (false discovery rate of 5%) from 26 studies. Most prioritized genes were located in Bos taurus autosomes 19 and 7, and most top-ranked genes were from the cytokine superfamily (e.g., chemokines, interleukins, transforming growth factors, and tumor necrosis factor genes). Although most prioritized genes (397) were associated with somatic cell count-related traits, only 54 genes were associated with clinical mastitis-related traits. Twenty-four genes (ABCC9, ACHE, ADCYAP1, ARC, BCL2L1, CDKN1A, EPO, GABBR2, GDNF, GNRHR, IKBKE, JAG1, KCNJ8, KCNQ1, LIFR, MC3R, MYOZ3, NFKB1, OSMR, PPP3CA, PRLR, SHARPIN, SLC1A3, and TNFRSF25) were reported for both somatic cell count and clinical mastitis-related traits. Prioritized genes were mainly associated with immune response, regulation of secretion, locomotion, cell proliferation, and development. In conclusion, this study provided a fine-mapping of previously identified genomic regions associated with resistance to mastitis and identified key functional candidate genes for resistance to mastitis, which can be used to develop enhanced genomic strategies to combat mastitis by increasing mastitis resistance through genetic selection.

Keywords

• bovine mastitis
• candidate gene
• systematic review
• gene prioritization
• genome-wide association study