Impact of reflective writings on learning of core competencies in medical residents

Abstract

Introduction: Reflection is a critical component of learning and improvement. It remains unclear as to how it can be effectively developed. We studied the impact of reflective writing in promoting deep reflection in the context of learning Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) competencies among residents in an Internal Medicine Residency programme. Methods: We used a convergent parallel mixed-methods design for this study in 2018. We analysed reflective writings for categories and frequencies of ACGME competencies covered and graded them for levels of reflection. We collected recently graduated residents’ perceptions of the value of reflective writings via individual semi-structured interviews. Results: We interviewed nine (out of 27) (33%) participants and analysed 35 reflective writings. 30 (86%) of the writings showed a deep level (grade A or B) of reflection. Participants reflected on all six ACGME competencies, especially ‘patient care’. Participants were reluctant to write but found benefits of increased understanding, self-awareness and ability to deal with similar future situations, facilitation of self-evaluation and emotional regulation. Supervisors’ guidance and feedback were lacking. Conclusion: We found that a reflective writing programme within an Internal Medicine Residency programme promoted deep reflection. Participants especially used self-reflection to enhance their skills in patient care. We recognised the important role of mentor guidance and feedback in enhancing reflective learning.

Keywords

• reflective writing
• acgme competencies
• internal medicine
• residency