Meteorologische Zeitschrift (Jul 2021)
Physical limits of wind energy within the atmosphere and its use as renewable energy: From the theoretical basis to practical implications
Abstract
How much wind energy does the atmosphere generate, and how much of it can at best be used as renewable energy? This review aims to give physically-based answers to both questions, providing first-order estimates and sensitivities that are consistent with those obtained from numerical simulation models. The first part describes how thermodynamics determines how much wind energy the atmosphere is physically capable of generating at large scales from the solar radiative forcing. The work done to generate and maintain large-scale atmospheric motion can be seen as the consequence of an atmospheric heat engine, which is driven by the difference in solar radiative heating between the tropics and the poles. The resulting motion transports heat, which depletes this differential solar heating and the associated, large-scale temperature difference, which drives this energy conversion in the first place. This interaction between the thermodynamic driver (temperature difference) and the resulting dynamics (heat transport) is critical for determining the maximum power that can be generated. It leads to a maximum in the global mean generation rate of kinetic energy of about 1.7 W m−2 and matches rates inferred from observations of about 2.1–2.5 W m−2 very well. This represents less than 1 % of the total absorbed solar radiation that is converted into kinetic energy. Although it would seem that the atmosphere is extremely inefficient in generating motion, thermodynamics shows that the atmosphere works as hard as it can to generate the energy contained in the winds. The second part focuses on the limits of converting the kinetic energy of the atmosphere into renewable energy. Considering the momentum balance of the lower atmosphere shows that at large-scales, only a fraction of about 26 % of the kinetic energy can at most be converted to renewable energy, consistent with insights from climate model simulations. This yields a typical resource potential in the order of 0.5 W m−2 per surface area in the global mean. The apparent discrepancy with much higher yields of single wind turbines and small wind farms can be explained by the spatial scale of about 100 km at which kinetic energy near the surface is being dissipated and replenished. I close with a discussion of how these insights are compatible to established meteorological concepts, inform practical applications for wind resource estimations, and, more generally, how such physical concepts, particularly limits regarding energy conversion, can set the basis for doing climate science in a simple, analytical, and transparent way.
Keywords
