Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Global Open (Apr 2018)

Buried Versus Exposed Kirschner Wires Following Fixation of Hand Fractures: l Clinician and Patient Surveys

  • WIRE Research Collaborative,
  • Matthew D. Gardiner,
  • Sonya Gardiner,
  • Fadi Issa,
  • Abhilash Jain,
  • Hawys Lloyd-Hughes,
  • Theodore Pezas,
  • Jeremy N. Rodrigues,
  • Justin C. R. Wormald,
  • Frank Acquaah,
  • Neil Brierley,
  • Shixin Bickerton,
  • Whitney Chow,
  • Juliet Clutton,
  • Samuel Coulson,
  • Pat Crowley,
  • Sarah Jayne Edmondson,
  • Andy Fowler,
  • Michael Gallagher,
  • Sophie Howles,
  • Jonathan Jones,
  • Lubna Khan,
  • Dharini Kulendran,
  • Clare Langley,
  • Robert Manton,
  • Mohamed Mohamed,
  • Lisa Ng,
  • Andrej Salibi,
  • Gujral Sameer,
  • Nic Segaren,
  • Kavita Sharma,
  • Andreas Shiatis,
  • Kathryn Steele,
  • Camilla Jay-Stewart,
  • Cindy Suwito,
  • Amy Tam,
  • Arron Thind,
  • Ryckie Wade,
  • Natasha Wielogorska,
  • Katie Young

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1097/GOX.0000000000001747
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 6, no. 4
p. e1747

Abstract

Read online

Background:. Fractures of the metacarpals and phalanges are common. Placement of Kirschner wires (K-wires) is the most common form of surgical fixation. After placement, a key decision is whether to bury the end of a K-wire or leave it protruding from the skin (exposed). A recent systematic review found no evidence to support either approach. The aim of study was to investigate current clinical practice, understand the key factors influencing clinician decision-making, and explore patient preferences to inform the design of a randomized clinical trial. Methods:. The steering group developed surveys for hand surgeons, hand therapists, and patients. Following piloting, they were distributed across the United Kingdom hand surgery units using the Reconstructive Surgery Trials Network. Results:. A total of 423 hand surgeons, 187 hand therapists, and 187 patients completed the surveys. Plastic surgeons and junior surgical trainees preferred to leave K-wires not buried. Ease of removal correlated with a decision to leave wires exposed, whereas perceived risk of infection correlated with burying wires. Cost did not affect the decision. Hand therapists were primarily concerned about infection and patient-related outcomes. Patients were most concerned about wire-related problems and pain. Conclusion:. This national survey provides a new understanding of the use of K-wires to manage hand fractures in the United Kingdom. A number of nonevidence-based factors seem to influence the decision to bury or leave K-wires exposed. The choice has important clinical and health economic implications that justify a randomized controlled trial.