Evaluating the Measurement Uncertainty of On-Road NOx Using a Portable Emission Measurement System (PEMS) Based on Real Testing Data in China

Abstract

An evaluation of the measurement uncertainty of on-road NOx emissions using portable emission measurement system (PEMS) based on real local testing data collected in China was carried out as per the type B method defined in the EN 17507 standard. The aim of this work was to quantify the “absolute” measurement uncertainty of PEMSs, which excluded “PEMS relative to laboratory constant volume sampler (CVS)” uncertainty from the calculation of on-road NOx measurement uncertainty using PEMSs. PEMS instruments from three mainstream manufacturers were employed. The zero drift of the NOx analyzers was evaluated periodically during the real driving emissions (RDE) test, and it was noticed that there was neither a linear nor step model of zero drift, with no correlation with the boundary conditions or measurement principle. Additionally, from the 256 valid RDE tests, the zero drift always ranged from 3.8 ppm to −3.8 ppm, and more than 95% of the span drifts were within a range of 1.5%. Based on the laboratory testing of ten vehicles using the worldwide harmonized light-duty vehicle test cycle (WLTC), the type B uncertainty of PEMS NOx measurements corresponding to China-6a and China-6b limits was assessed. An uncertainty of 26.5% for China-6a was found (NOx limit = 60 mg/km over the WLTC), which is very close to the 22.5% from the EU evaluation results (NOx limit = 80 mg/km over the WLTC); the uncertainty with respect to China-6b was found to be 42.8% because the type-I limit was tuned down to 35 mg/km. This result indicates that, with the ever-tightening regulatory limits of vehicle NOx emissions, big challenges will be posed in terms of the reliability of PEMS measurements, which requires PEMS manufacturers to improve the performance of the instruments and policymakers to refine the test procedures and/or result calculation method to minimize the impacts.

Keywords

• PEMS
• type B uncertainty
• NOx
• petrol vehicles
• zero drift
• span drift