mBio (Dec 2024)
Performance of rapid antigen tests to detect SARS-CoV-2 variant diversity and correlation with viral culture positivity: implication for diagnostic development and future public health strategies
Abstract
ABSTRACT Antigen-based rapid diagnostic tests (Ag-RDTs) provide timely results, are simple to use, and are less expensive than molecular assays. Recent studies suggest that antigen-based testing aligns with virus culture-based results (a proxy of contagiousness at the peak viral phase of illness); however, the performance of Ag-RDTs for newer SARS-CoV-2 variants is unclear. In this study, we (i) assessed the performance of Ag-RDTs and diagnostic antibodies to detect a range of SARS-CoV-2 variants and (ii) determined whether Ag-RDT results correlated with culture positivity. We noted only minor differences in the limit of detection by variant for all assays, and we demonstrated consistent antibody affinity to the N protein among the different variants. We observed moderate to high sensitivity (46.8%–83.9%) for Ag-RDTs when compared to PCR positivity (100%), and all variants were assessed on each assay. Ag-RDT sensitivity and PCR Ct showed an inverse correlation with the detection of viable virus. Collectively, our results demonstrate that commercially available Ag-RDTs offer variable sensitivity compared to PCR, show similar diagnostic validity across variants, and may predict the risk of transmissibility. These findings may be used to support more tailored SARS-CoV-2 isolation strategies, particularly if other studies clarify the direct association between Ag-RDT positivity and transmission risk. The apparent trade-off between sensitivity in the detection of any PCR-positive infection and concordance with infectious virus positivity may also inform new RDT diagnostic development strategies for SARS-CoV-2 and other epidemic respiratory pathogens.IMPORTANCEDespite the availability of vaccines, COVID-19 continues to be a major health concern, and antigen-based rapid diagnostic tests (Ag-RDTs) are commonly used as point-of-care or at-home diagnostic tests. In this study, we evaluated the performance of two commercially available Ag-RDTs and a research Ag-RDT to detect multiple SARS-CoV-2 variants using upper respiratory tract swab samples from clinical COVID-19 cases. Furthermore, we determined whether Ag-RDT results correlated with culture positivity, a potential proxy of viral transmissibility. Our results have important implications to inform future testing and response strategies during periods of high COVID-19 transmission with new variants.
Keywords
