Radiation Oncology (Dec 2009)

3D-conformal Accelerated Partial Breast Irradiation treatment planning: the value of surgical clips in the delineation of the lumpectomy cavity

  • Rimareix Françoise,
  • Garbay Jean-Rémy,
  • Uzan Catherine,
  • Gouy Sébastien,
  • Khallel Adel,
  • Pessoa Eduardo,
  • Dunant Ariane,
  • Pichenot Charlotte,
  • Tournay Elodie,
  • Dzhugashvili Maia,
  • Spielmann Marc,
  • Vielh Philippe,
  • Marsiglia Hugo,
  • Bourgier Céline

DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/1748-717X-4-70
Journal volume & issue
Vol. 4, no. 1
p. 70

Abstract

Read online

Abstract Background Accurate localisation of the lumpectomy cavity (LC) volume is one of the most critical points in 3D-conformal Partial breast irradiation (3D-APBI) treatment planning because the irradiated volume is restricted to a small breast volume. Here, we studied the role of the placement of surgical clips at the 4 cardinal points of the lumpectomy cavity in target delineation. Methods Forty CT-based 3D-APBI plans were retrieved on which a total of 4 radiation oncologists, two trainee and two experienced physicians, outlined the lumpectomy cavity. The inter-observer variability of LC contouring was assessed when the CTV was defined as the delineation that encompassed both surgical clips and remodelled breast tissue. Results The conformity index of tumour bed delineation was significantly improved by the placement of surgical clips within the LC (median at 0.65). Furthermore, a better conformity index of LC was observed according to the experience of the physicians (median CI = 0.55 for trainee physicians vs 0.65 for experienced physicians). Conclusions The placement of surgical clips improved the accuracy of lumpectomy cavity delineation in 3D-APBI. However, a learning curve is needed to improve the conformity index of the lumpectomy cavity.