Coping and Recovery in Surgical Residents after Adverse Events: The Second Victim Phenomenon

Abstract

Background:. The second victim phenomenon is the distress felt by healthcare providers after a medical error. Although the phenomenon is a significant risk factor for burnout, little has been written about it in surgery, especially among residents. Methods:. After institutional review board approval, a 27-question anonymous online survey was sent to plastic surgery residents throughout the United States, and to residents from all surgical specialties at our institution, for a total of 435 residents. Residents were asked to describe any adverse events they had experienced, and subsequent emotional sequelae. Results:. The survey was returned by 125 residents (response rate 28.7%), of whom 53 were plastic surgery residents (42.4%) and 72 were from other surgical specialties (57.6%). In total, 110 (88%) described having been part of a medical error. An estimated 74 residents (34 from plastic surgery, 40 from other surgical specialties) provided a detailed description of the event. Sixty-four of them (86.5%) had subsequent emotional sequelae, most commonly guilt, anxiety, and insomnia. Only 24.3% of residents received emotional support. They rated other residents as the most important source of support, followed by faculty members and then family/friends. Conclusions:. The second victim phenomenon seems to be common among surgical residents. The most important source of support for affected residents in our cohort was other residents. Given these findings, institutions should focus on fostering camaraderie among residents, building effective second victim response teams and training peer support specialists.