Performance Comparison of Deep Learning (DL)-Based Tabular Models for Building Mapping Using High-Resolution Red, Green, and Blue Imagery and the Geographic Object-Based Image Analysis Framework

Abstract

Identifying urban buildings in high-resolution RGB images presents challenges, mainly due to the absence of near-infrared bands in UAVs and Google Earth imagery and the diversity in building attributes. Deep learning (DL) methods, especially Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs), are widely used for building extraction but are primarily pixel-based. Geographic Object-Based Image Analysis (GEOBIA) has emerged as an essential approach for high-resolution imagery. However, integrating GEOBIA with DL models presents challenges, including adapting DL models for irregular-shaped segments and effectively merging DL outputs with object-based features. Recent developments include tabular DL models that align well with GEOBIA. GEOBIA stores various features for image segments in a tabular format, yet the effectiveness of these tabular DL models for building extraction still needs to be explored. It also needs to clarify which features are crucial for distinguishing buildings from other land-cover types. Typically, GEOBIA employs shallow learning (SL) classifiers. Thus, this study evaluates SL and tabular DL classifiers for their ability to differentiate buildings from non-building features. Furthermore, these classifiers are assessed for their capacity to handle roof heterogeneity caused by sun exposure and roof materials. This study concludes that some SL classifiers perform similarly to their DL counterparts, and it identifies critical features for building extraction.

Keywords

• building extraction
• GEOBIA
• deep learning
• tabular model
• SVM
• RF