Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience (Aug 2023)

Neurocognitive basis of model-based decision making and its metacontrol in childhood

  • C.R. Smid,
  • K. Ganesan,
  • A. Thompson,
  • R. Cañigueral,
  • S. Veselic,
  • J. Royer,
  • W. Kool,
  • T.U. Hauser,
  • B. Bernhardt,
  • N. Steinbeis

Journal volume & issue
Vol. 62
p. 101269

Abstract

Read online

Human behavior is supported by both goal-directed (model-based) and habitual (model-free) decision-making, each differing in its flexibility, accuracy, and computational cost. The arbitration between habitual and goal-directed systems is thought to be regulated by a process known as metacontrol. However, how these systems emerge and develop remains poorly understood. Recently, we found that while children between 5 and 11 years displayed robust signatures of model-based decision-making, which increased during this developmental period, there were substantial individual differences in the display of metacontrol. Here, we inspect the neurocognitive basis of model-based decision-making and metacontrol in childhood and focus this investigation on executive functions, fluid reasoning, and brain structure. A total of 69 participants between the ages of 6–13 completed a two-step decision-making task and an extensive behavioral test battery. A subset of 44 participants also completed a structural magnetic resonance imaging scan. We find that individual differences in metacontrol are specifically associated with performance on an inhibition task and individual differences in thickness of dorsolateral prefrontal, temporal, and superior-parietal cortices. These brain regions likely reflect the involvement of cognitive processes crucial to metacontrol, such as cognitive control and contextual processing.

Keywords