Scared, Bored or Happy? Latent Profile Analyses of Primary School Students’ Academic Emotions about Math

Abstract

Emotions and motivation are central to learning. Control–value theory (CVT) and expectancy–value theory (EVT) explain how emotions and expectations of success affect students’ task engagement. Supported by these two frameworks, this study investigates the emotion profiles for maths among fourth- and fifth-grade students (N = 6778) from three European countries and their links to motivation and achievement. Methods: Using latent profile analysis (LPA), we analysed the emotional profiles in students, as well as their associations with gender, country, grade, motivation and maths achievement. Results: Five profiles emerged in the grade 4 data (Bored, Bored and Anxious, Moderate, Happy and Anxious). All five profiles were visible in the grade 5 data, coupled with an additional sixth profile, which appeared only in grade 5 (i.e., Apprehensive–Happy). Girls were found more commonly in the Anxious profile and were less likely to appear in the Happy profile. Norwegian students were more prominent in the Bored and Moderate profiles. Conversely, Portuguese students stood out more in the Anxious profile and were less present in the Bored and Moderate profiles. The Serbian dataset did not stand out, with a particular pattern observed in grade 4. Nevertheless, Serbian fifth graders were overly visible in the Bored and Anxious profile and less present in the Happy and Apprehensive–Happy groups. The Happy profile had higher scores for all task values except for cost and was, along with the Moderate profile, associated with higher achievement; the Bored and Anxious profile was associated with higher scores of cost value and lower achievement. Conclusions: A person-centred approach allowed for a more diverse view of how students experience emotions. These findings highlight the complex interplay between emotions, motivation and achievement, which is affected by cultural and educational contexts.

Keywords

• emotion profiles
• mathematics
• primary school
• LPA
• cross-country comparison