Topographic evolution of heat-treated Nb upon electropolishing for superconducting rf applications

Abstract

Surface finish plays an essential role in the performance of superconducting radio frequency cavities. Several surface treatments have been developed to reduce surface resistance at a moderate accelerating gradient. We investigated the effects of sequential electropolishing on samples vacuum heat-treated at 300 and 600 °C and N-doped Nb samples using atomic force microscopy. The N-doping process precipitates niobium nitrides within grains and, most notably, continuously and deeply along some grain boundaries. Upon electropolishing, the nitrides are preferentially removed leaving behind a topographically imperfect surface marked by relatively deep holes and grooves with low radius of curvature edges. The progression of magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors upon electropolishing were investigated using atomic force micrographs. While minor changes in magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors are observed for the 300 and 600 °C heat-treated Nb, substantial improvements are observed for N-doped Nb. In this system, the most severe topographic defects are the grain boundary grooves which substantially suppress the superheating field. We find that the severity of topographic defects is related to the N-doping process.