Does liquid nitrogen recycled autograft for treatment of bone sarcoma impact local recurrence rate? A systematic review

Abstract

The gold standard treatment for primary bone sarcomas has been surgical resection with wide margins. However, there is no consensus regarding an optimal method for limb salvage reconstruction. In 2005, a technique for recycling resected bone after intraoperative treatment with liquid nitrogen was described. This technique has been reported to have a spectrum of advantages; nonetheless, acceptance for routine use has been limited, primarily for fear of local recurrence. A systematic search of the literature using PubMed and Google Scholar was performed. Full-text articles published between 2008 and 2023 were included if the study presented sufficient information regarding patients with a diagnosis of a primary bone sarcoma of the limbs or pelvis who had undergone reconstruction with liquid nitrogen recycled autografts. Sixteen studies that included 286 patients met criteria for analyses. Local recurrence occurred in 25 patients (8.7 %) during the first 4 years following limb salvage reconstruction using recycled autografts for treatment of primary bone sarcomas, which compares favorably to the 15–30 % local recurrence rates reported for patients undergoing limb salvage reconstruction using artificial implants. Systematic synthesis of the current evidence regarding local recurrence rates following use of the liquid nitrogen recycled autograft technique for limb salvage reconstruction after bone sarcoma resection suggests a favorable comparison to other limb salvage reconstruction options. As such, this technique warrants further consideration as a viable option for indicated patients based on relative advantages regarding costs, availability, and biologic and surgical reconstruction benefits.

Keywords

• Bone sarcoma
• Recycled autograft
• Liquid nitrogen